Debate the Position, Not the Person

Debate a position, not a person. It is critical when debating a topic to avoid impugning the credibility of those who take an opposing stance.

Example 1: I don't care for rap, because it lacks a traditional melody.

Example 2: Anyone who listens to rap is an idiot.

The latter approach is known as an ad hominem attack and it is never helpful. By putting people on the defensive, we discourage logical thought and incite emotional reactions. Consensus becomes all but impossible under these conditions.

Ad hominem attacks are popular in politics and in politically driven media outlets, but popularity does not make it correct.  

As with profanity, ad hominem attacks are intellectual shortcuts. They are reactive and devoid of reason. 

Avoid reactive thinking and force yourself to reason and communicate with precision and clarity. Hold yourself to a higher standard. 

Don't permit debates to become personal. Find fault with the position rather than the person. 

Copyright © 2014 Daniel R. South
All Rights Reserved